- 100 years of the best American short stories, edited by Lorrie Moore and Heidi Pitlor
- The best American short stories 2013, selected from U.S. and Canadian magazines, by Elizabeth Strout with Heidi Pitlor ; with an introduction by Elizabeth Strout
- The Best American Short Stories 2012, selected from U.S. and Canadian magazines, by Tom Perrotta and Heidi Pitlor ; with an introduction by Tom Perrotta
- The best American short stories 2015, selected from U.S. and Canadian magazines by T.C. Boyle with Heidi Pitlor ; with an introduction by T.C. Boyle
- The best American short stories 2014, selected from U.S. and Canadian magazines by Jennifer Egan with Heidi Pitlor ; with an introduction by Jennifer Egan
- It occurs to me that I am America, new stories and art, edited by Jonathan Santlofer ; introduction by Viet Thanh Nguyen
- The best American short stories 2020, selected from U.S. and Canadian magazines, by Curtis Sittenfeld with Heidi Pitlor